• Article highlight
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article History

Received : 20-07-2024

Accepted : 30-07-2024



Article Metrics




Downlaod Files

   


Article Access statistics

Viewed: 211

PDF Downloaded: 61


Get Permission Gupta: The silent threat: Fatigue, burnout, and patient safety in anaesthesia

Introduction

Anaesthetists are major players in patient safety and successful surgical outcomes. Job demands of long working hours, difficult shift work, and high levels of demands at work expose them to an increased risk of both fatigue and burnout. These issues pose a significant contemporaneous threat to the well-being of an anaesthetist and the safety of his or her patients. The editorial aims to bring attention to the burden and effects of fatigue and burnout in the practice of anesthesia and to call for comprehensive strategies that work toward mitigating these risks, ensuring the health and safety of both the practitioners and their patients.

The Nature of Anaesthesia Work

Anaesthesia is an exacting specialty for which high levels of cognitive function, vigilance, and decision-making skills are required.1, 2 Anaesthetists are responsible for the comprehensive care of patients before, during, and after surgery. They administer anaesthesia, meticulously monitor vital signs, and swiftly respond to any changes in the patient's condition. Additionally, they manage pain relief, provide critical life support, and ensure patient safety throughout the perioperative period, demonstrating their crucial role and high workload in patient care. Long working hours, more than 24 hours in a row, are common, with erratic shift patterns that without any doubt will disturb sleep and the body's circadian rhythm. Besides, the high level of stress involved in an operating room environment, along with possible complications and emergencies, means that their work is relevantly related to mental and physical health for anaesthetists. The harsh realities of long working hours, sleep deprivation, and burnout pose a grave threat to the well-being of anesthesia providers and the safety of their patients.3

Fatigue in Anaesthesia

Fatigue in the case of anesthetists is a very prevalent problem. Various studies have shown that up to 60.8% of them suffer from severe excessive daytime sleepiness.4 Factors contributing to fatigue may include long working hours, irregular shift patterns, mental stress and high workload. This can result in poor cognitive functioning and performance, decreasing vigilance, impairing decision-making, and reducing psychomotor skills.3, 5 Anesthesia residents have stated that fatigue interferes with both their professional and personal lives, with negative effects on their physical health.4

In a study by Kothari et al., it was concluded that there is a relationship between fatigue among anaesthetists and a higher incidence of medication errors and other adverse events.6 On the other hand, Stahel et al. concluded that the non-technical skills, such as communication and teamwork—who stand central in the forefront of patient safety—deteriorate because of tiredness.7 Fatigued anesthesiologists also exhibit decreased vigilance, psychomotor skills, and the ability to make sound clinical decisions.4

Burnout in Anaesthesia

Another major problem bothering anesthetists is burnout. According to studies, it represents as much as 54% of them who often experience this symptom.8 Burnout can be defined as emotional exhaustion, depersonalization, and reduced accomplishment related to personal views. The risks of developing these can be analytically directly linked to chronic stress, emotional requirements at work, and poor balance between work and private life.

Serious consequences of burnout in anaesthetists could include mental health problems or a long career that is nonsurvivable. Burnout significantly increases the risk of suicidal ideation among anesthesiologists. Evidence indicates that healthcare professionals have a heightened risk of suicide, with anesthetists being particularly vulnerable.9 In another research undertaken, burnout was a large predictor of early retirement among anaesthesiologists.10

Burnout can also affect patient safety, in which case anesthetists experiencing burnout may be more likely to make mistakes and deliver suboptimal care. It is also associated with an increased frequency of patient safety incidents and reduced patient satisfaction scores.11

Current Mitigation Strategies

The risks of fatigue and burnout are being addressed through a number of strategies, such as work hour regulations like the European Working Time Directive, which aims to restrict hours with provisions to provide adequate rest periods.12 Fatigue management programs, like the Australian and New Zealand College of Anaesthetists, have provided education and resources for an anaesthetist to recognize and manage their own fatigue.13

The wellness provisions in a healthcare institution only underscore the need for the provision of stress management workshops and mindfulness programs, among others, to help in the promotion of mental health and well-being among anaesthetists. Theses join a long list that requires much more comprehensive and systemic attention.14

Future Directions and Recommendations

Further studies are indicated to learn more about prevalence and impact characteristics of fatigue and burnout concerning anaesthetists and to determine the Strategic mitigation measures. Policy changes mandating rest periods, limiting work hours, and implementing other measures are essential to ensure the health and safety of anesthetists. These changes aim to alleviate risks and reduce the incidence of burnout and its associated consequences. This requires that hospitals and anesthesiology departments create a work environment in which open discussions of fatigue are acceptable, mental health resources are accessible, and mutual support and self-care are encouraged.4, 15 This will empower anesthesiologists and enable them to make decisions about their welfare without the fear of stigma and professional reprisal.

Conclusion

The alarming prevalence of fatigue among anesthesia providers and its detrimental impact on patient safety can no longer be ignored. Anesthesiologists, healthcare organizations, and regulatory bodies must work together to implement comprehensive strategies to mitigate fatigue and protect the well-being of both providers and patients. Addressing these issues requires an inclusive and systemic approach that prioritizes the health and safety of both anaesthetists and their patients. By working together, we can create a safer and more sustainable healthcare system for all.

It is not the strongest of the species that survive, nor the most intelligent, but the one most responsive to change.

— Darwin

Source of Funding

None.

Conflict of Interest

None.

References

1 

B Nair E Gabel I Hofer H Schwid M Cannesson Intraoperative clinical decision support for anesthesia: A narrative review of available systemAnesth Analg2017124260317

2 

AA Alshaalan MK Alharbi KA Alattas Preference of cognitive approaches for decision making among anesthesiologists' in Saudi ArabiaSaudi J Anaesth20191331916

3 

A Sinha A Singh A Tewari The fatigued anesthesiologist: A threat to patient safety?J Anaesthesiol Clin Pharmacol20132921519

4 

A Scholliers S Cornelis M Tosi T Opsomer D Shaproski C Vanlersberghe Impact of fatigue on anaesthesia providers: a scoping reviewBr J Anaesth2023130562235

5 

M Ippolito S Einav A Giarratano A Cortegiani Effects of fatigue on anaesthetist well-being and patient safety: a narrative reviewBr J Anaesth202413311117

6 

D Kothari S Gupta C Sharma S Kothari Medication error in anaesthesia and critical care: A cause for concernIndian J Anaesth201054318792

7 

PF Stahel L Cobianchi FD Mas S Paterson-Brown BE Sakakushev C Nguyen The role of teamwork and non-technical skills for improving emergency surgical outcomes: an international perspectivePatient Saf Surg20221618

8 

J Berger-Estilita D Salvisberg E Köselerli S Haupt BC Meço Impact of Burnout on AnaesthesiologistsTurk J Anaesthesiol Reanim2024522549

9 

E Plunkett A Costello S M Yentis K Hawton Suicide in anaesthetists: a systematic reviewAnaesthesia2021761013921403

10 

ARC Sousa JIDB Mourão Burnout in anesthesiologyBraz J Anesthesiol201868550717

11 

CL Garcia LC Abreu JLS Ramos CFDd Castro FRN Smiderle JAD Santos Influence of Burnout on Patient Safety: Systematic Review and Meta-AnalysisMedicina (Kaunas)2019559553

12 

J Cabrita Y Torres-Revenga Opting out of the European Working Time Directive2015Eurofoundhttps://www.eurofound.europa.eu/en/publications/2015/opting-out-european-working-time-directive

13 

Healthdirect Australia ANZCA – Australian and New Zealand College of Anaesthetists2023HealthdirectAustraliahttps://www.healthdirect.gov.au/partners/anzca-australian-and-new-zealand-college-of-anaesthetists

14 

EP Nwobodo B Strukcinskiene A Razbadauskas R Grigoliene C Agostinis-Sobrinho Stress Management in Healthcare Organizations: The Nigerian ContextHealthcare (Basel)202311212815

15 

N Gupta A Gupta R Garg Professional burnout in anaesthesia and critical care - How to decrease itJ Anesth Crit Care Open Access2015256



jats-html.xsl


This is an Open Access (OA) journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.